Player ratings: Munster vs Ulster

Player ratings: Munster vs Ulster

Munster


1. Dave Kilcoyne - 8/10

Very solid performance as the Munster front row. Dominated at scrum time and carried powerfully.



2. Niall Scannell - 8/10
 
 
Another solid performer in the front row. Great work rate around the field with some strong carries.
 
3. John Ryan - 9/10
 
Continuing his strong run of form with another impressive display. An immovabe object at the scrum.
 
4. Donnacha Ryan - 7/10
 
Great work rate, very effective off the ball.
 
5. Billy Holland - 6/10
 
Gave away some needless penalties and had a quiet afternoon overall.
 
6. Peter O'Mahony - 8/10
 
 
Lead his side with a dogged performance with great work at the breakdown and an eagerness to carry.
 
7. Tommy O'Donnell - 7/10
 
Did well on the ground to disrupt Ulster ball and made some good break away runs.
 
8. Jack O'Donoghue - 7/10
 
Only saw 45 minutes of game time but showed his quality as a ball carrier in the first half.
 
9. Angus Lloyd - 8/10
 
Distributed well and brought great pace to the attack. Produced a number of clever territorial kicks giving his side key field position.
 
10. Ian Keatley - 6/10
 
Had a solid first half performance with good distribution and tactical kicking.
 
11. Keith Earls - 9/10
 
 
A man of the match performance for his ever threatening presence on the wing. Did very little wrong and scored the winning try.
 
12. Rory Scannell - 7/10
 
A solid defensive performance from the young center before having to go off with an ankle injury.
 
13. Francis Saili - 8/10
 
Saili was a potent attacking threat with his pace causing huge problems for the Ulster defence.
 
14. Darren Sweetnam - N/A
 
Unfortunate to have to leave the game after two minutes with an injury. Had no time to impress.
 
15. Simon Zebo 8/10
 
 
An energetic performance, brilliant under the high ball and on the counter attack.
 
16. Rhys Marshall (66') -  6/10
 
 
17. James Cronin (56') - 7/10
 
 
18. Stephen Archer N/A
 
 
19. Dave O'Callaghan (60') - 8/10
 
Scored a try soon after coming on. Strong work rate and made his presence felt at the breakdown.
 
20. Jean Deysel (45') - 7/10
 
Made an impact when he came on at number 8. 
 
21. Abrie Griesel (50') - 7/10
 
 
22. Tyler Bleyendaal (44') - 8/10
 
Very effective when he came on with his accurate boot impressing.
 
23.  Andrew Conway (2') - 6/10
 
Made some nice runs on the wing but had a relatively quiet afternoon.
 
 
 
Ulster
 
 
 
1. Andrew Warwick – 6/10

Solid at scrum time. Carried powerfully but slow to get to rucks at times.


2. Rory Best – 7/10

Put in a solid shift at the breakdown and in defence. Lineouts a little bit hit and miss but made up for it with a try.


3. Wiehaan Herbst – 7/10

Solid at scrum time. Consistently hit rucks and made his tackles.


4. Kieran Treadwell – 7/10

Very physical at the breakdown and an impressive option at the lineout.


5. Alan O’Connor – 6/10

Quiet afternoon from the second rower. Made his tackles and hit a decent number of rucks.


6. Iain Henderson – 7/10
 


Impressive in attack, ran intelligent lines and carried effectively. Few unfortunate handling errors.


7. Chris Henry – 7/10

Unfortunately forced off early through injury but had been solid until then.


8. Sean Reidy – 7/10

Stand out performer in the Ulster pack. Carried dynamically and was a menace at the breakdown.


9. Ruan Pienaar – 8/10

Classy as always. Marshalled the backline expertly with accurate passing and some intelligent kicking.


10. Paddy Jackson – 7/10

Attacked the line impressively and showed good awareness. A few poorly executed kicks out of ahnd.


11. Charles Piutau – 7/10

Quiet afternoon by his own standards but still put in a solid attacking display and caused the Munster defence problems.


12. Stuart Olding – 6/10

Pretty quiet afternoon for the usually impressive centre. Made his tackles when called upon but ineffectual in attack.


13. Luke Marshall – 8/10
 


Stand out performer in the backline. Posed a constant threat in attack and scored an excellent try. Solid in defence and very hard working at the breakdown.


14. Andrew Trimble – 5/10

Relatively poor performance from the Ulster captain. Had some good chances but lacked clinical decision making skills which ultimately cost Ulster.


15. Jacob Stockdale – 7/10

Impressive performance for the young full back. Caused a host of problems with his pace and power.


16. Rob Herring – 7/10 (50’)

Made a solid impact off the bench; good lineout throws and high work rate in defence.



17. Callum Black – 6/10 (63’)

Pretty anonymous off the bench. Solid at scrum time but failed to make a significant impact on the outcome of the game.


18. Rodney Ah You – (73’) N/A


19. Robbie Diack – 6/10 (70’)

Solid impact off the bench. Good lineout option and solid defensively.


20. Clive Ross – 7/10 (28’)

Put in a very solid shift having been called upon early to replace the injured Chris Henry. A menace at the breakdown and dangerous with ball in hand.


21. Paul Marshall – N/A


22. Stuart McCloskey – 7/10 (51’)

Very impressive coming off the bench. Posed a constant threat with ball in hand and had the Munster defence stretched at times.


23. Craig Gilroy – 6/10 (61’)

Failed to make a really significant impact on the game. Ran some intelligent lines but was contained impressively by the Munster defence.
 

Latest News